Trinity Sunday:

The Trinity as

The Trinity as “The Dance Around” as movement, flow, divine relationship.. la dansa, by Matisse

New Jersey is known as the garden state. At one time its farms supplied among other products, millions of tomatoes to Campbell’s Soup Company in Camden. Still in South Jersey acres of blueberries and other vegetables grow in the sandy soil. Large parts of the state are beautiful. The long sand beaches of the Jersey shore, the Pine Barrens in the east and South under which lies hidden one of the most pristine aquafers in the US. Along stretches of the Delaware River Northeast to the Delaware Water gap, Red Hawks soar from the cliffs that overhang the river.

Because of its farming legacy, sited around the state are old grist mills. A grist mill relied on water to propel a massive water-wheel to power the mill stones that ground wheat, corn and other grains to flour.

Allentown, NJ has such a mill wheel. It has not been used for probably a century, but the old structure had survived up until 2000. Twenty –five or more feet in diameter, the machinery of wood and iron took water from a sluice which spilled it into wooden iron-bound buckets that moved the gigantic wheel into motion.

Some have seen the Trinity like a mill wheel. The flow of the waterfall, spilling into one another: The love and laughter of the Father, spilling with roaring joy into the Son, and the complete self-emptying of the Son spilling into the Holy Spirit. Finally returning over and over into a delight in the ongoing process of birth, dying in to self and re-invention. In its movement and joy the Spirit, the inner genius and generosity of the heart, spills over into creation and thus, into us: Love spilling over into love, grace into grace, peace into peace, hope into hope, joy into joy, and wonder into wonder.

Cynthia Bourgeautlt, in The Wisdom Jesus writes:

“The Trinity, understood in a wisdom sense, is really an icon of self-emptying love. The three persons go round and round like buckets on a watermill, constantly over spilling into one another. As they do so, the mill turns and the energy of love becomes manifest and accessible.” From early times in the life of the Christian community, the Trinity was called the “dance around” or perichoresis. This “wonderful and profound insight is that God reveals God’s innermost nature through a continuous round dance of self-emptying. On the great watermill of the Trinity, the statement, “God is love” brings itself into reality.” *

That’s why I value the Trinity is a song to be sung rather than a doctrine by which we become dangerously rigid and closed. We still sometimes sing the creed, placing chords under the single note that we start with.

“Do you want to know what the Trinity

is? Asks Meister Eckhart:


 ”The Father laughs and begets the Son, The Son laughs and begets the Spirit, the Spirit laughs and begets us.” And in our creative and loving action we laugh and continue the great mill wheel of God’s self-emptying love.

God so loved the world that he gave his Son that all humans and all creation would know the gracious outpouring of God’s love, the son came to save us from our predisposition to cynicism and despair. The son came to show us how we can become adopted children of the One who created the Son. The son came to show us this very unique way to become One with the Holy Spirit, by a constant giving away of compassion, presence, love and commitment to the well-being of all.

And so the Prophet is set on fire with the Word of God. Paul finds these absolutely brilliant sentences in his letter to Rome, that we hope for what is not immediately seen. To us the hidden sanctity of the creation is revealed, and out of that knowing of the love of the divine for the world, we give it back, return what has been given so lavishly to us, to the water-wheel of God’s love and it keeps going.

Each act of kindness contributing to the flow of love and energy, just like Jesus. And the river runs and the wheel turns and we, well we, either stand by and watch the river of life go by or we step or jump into the flow.

*The Wisdom Jesus, Cynthia Bourgeault, Shambhala 2008.

PENTECOSTS Are Happening All the Time

Pentecost, Year B.

We named our organization Project ACTS: We were an Ecumenical Organization of about fifteen Churches in Roslindale and Hyde Park, two Boston neighborhoods. It was 1981 and we’d been working to draw together the congregations in an inaugural convention. There was a Greek Orthodox Church, Two Large Roman Catholic congregations and a salad bowl of our Protestant denominations. At the Founding Convention came various bishops and heads of judicatories. Each congregation and religious organization put aside their differences in a common effort to make the communities more responsive to the needs of our youth, to affordable housing and to quality of life issues. Each church arrived with delegations of various sizes to St Nectarios Church, a young community of many Greek speakers. Almost as if we were returning to that initial Pentecost when all the boundaries and the confusions of languages and customs were removed, we stood together in the power of the love of God and the Spirit and a common purpose.

Our small Episcopal congregation rented space in the Lutheran Church, yet our “little old ladies” were a force with which to contend. Jean Dubois, our organizer, worked with issues of conflict between members that had been in the making for generations. She held us accountable to talk with the congregation and the neighbors. Out of the meetings grew a summer camp program for the children and a meeting with the neighbors about the drunken and noisy parties on weekend nights in the Lutheran Church parking lot. When the police conducted a “raid” on the parking lot, one of our own youth had been picked up by the police. That night I had to go to the police lock-up to get him out.

We had to think more broadly: What do our youth want, what are their needs, where are the programs and facilities in our communities to offer alternatives? Facilities and programs had fled to the wealthier neighborhoods and suburbs. The Municipal building that occupied a large corner of the neighborhood center had closed its gym, operated by the Boys Club and the Registry of Motor Vehicles was threatened for closure and to be moved to the nearby suburbs. Also a swimming pool had been closed after a youth drove a VW through the fence and into the swimming pool. The local city councilor, biased to the core, said that pool would never be restored. He insinuated that the poor people in that area of the town didn’t deserve it. Our little parish was doing Bible Study with the residents of low-income housing development in that neighborhood. We knew better.

The Pentecost moments were many. One of them was the day Governor Dukakis came to cut the ribbon for the re-opening of the Municipal Building. Our “little old ladies” were all arranged in the front row. Their hair all permed that morning, they smiled at the Governor who was flanked by two enormous and armed State Troopers. The State had invested considerable resources to renovate the old Registry of Motor Vehicles. The Boys Club had received grants to refurbish the old gym and track in the building with a new floor and locker rooms. And the Boys club agreed to add “and Girls” to the name. Also the Health Center had succeeded in getting a grant to refurbish the other third of the building. There was such joy in that room that day and a sense of accomplishment. All of our churches crowded the room and our small vagabond church helped to lead the way.

When I visited the registry the next day, I found I had become a local celebrity. They called me over to the window and gave me an honorary registration card. Not bad for a kid who was arrested for driving unregistered and uninsured ten years before.

The organization also had success in re-opening the community pool. The city gave 5.7 million dollars for its reconstruction. Oversight of the operation fell to an inter-racial community board which included many people from that lower income part of the neighborhood.

That initial work helped transform those neighborhoods and it became the model of a way of thinking about neighborhoods in the city that helped elect the next mayor, Tom Menino. Tom died in 2014, after serving well and kindly for twenty years.

“Being One” Easter 7b

“That they all may be one, like us.”,  John 17,  New Jerusalem Bible

The work of the ecumenical movement of the 60’s and 70’s led to the common lectionary and to this blog.The lectionary is a three year cycle of readings from the Hebrew and Christian scriptures that are read aloud each Sunday in a majority of Christian communities. I receive notices from all over the world because of the lectionary and also the work of and FB. So ecumenism does work.

Frank Cloherty, the Roman Catholic priest in a nearby parish, called my home one day. He wanted to know if I’d be interested in ARC, the Anglican-Roman Catholic dialogue. It was 1976, the same year, I think that we developed the Common Lectionary. I was ecstatic. “Yes!” I replied.

The text for this Sunday was Frank’s seminal text for what it meant to be the Church: the movement into oneness, into the living body of the Christ, where there is only knowing and no separation. And as often is the case, the Church, when it talks about Oneness, is usually faced with its divisions. Indeed, in my growing up years, our separations were paramount. “Why are we unique, what is our special identity, how is the other wrong and we are right.”

One of the great blessings of my youth was my step-dad. My father was killed in WWII. Even now when I think of it, although he was in the US Air Force, the grief due to the death of a parent from violence has no national or racial boundaries. My step-Dad was Roman Catholic. In my teens I teethed on infuriating him with ideas I was bringing home from school. He was a bright and conservative man. I admired him for his devotional life. He went to church on all the Holy Days. He seldom missed Church on Sunday. He had been taught not to enter a Protestant church. When he married my mother who refused to become a  Roman Catholic, they had to be  married in the rectory rather than in the church. At twelve, when I was confirmed in the Episcopal Church, what joy I felt and respect when Dad came to the church. I saw him look around the building and wondered if he might be anxious that the roof would fall in on him.

Well, Frank became a good friend. He participated with me when my son Christopher was born and was our youngest child’s Godfather. We would hike into the mountains and come down after a long sweaty trek to a six pack of beer we had left in the mountain stream at the base of the trail. We did years of Bible study and sermon preparation time together.

It’s all about oneness. For many of us in the West, it is becoming that unity modeled between Christ and the Divine. In that unity he was able to see beyond all outward divisions to draw out the heart of love in all whom he encountered. And yet the world is so founded upon division, tribalism, right and wrong, us and them.

Jesus and the wisdom masters, such as the Dalai Lama, offer another way: To learn to see with the One eye, to see not only with the mind but through the eye of the heart. To practice love of neighbor where there’s no longer any separation, that we are all in this life together: is the Oneness Jesus is getting at.

As Jesse Jackson famously quoted the old spiritual: “We all came on different ships, but we’re all in the same boat now”, we are a unity of being, now dwelling on One planet and either we love the earth and learn to live in deep peace with all her beings, or we will remain stuck in a spiritual wilderness.

Jesus extends an invitation to live into the Oneness of being. Our competitions are an illusion, built on a mind of us and them, of right and wrong, win and lose. Instead we can chose to live with a different mind; a mind that is connected the fourteen inches to the heart. It is in the heart connected mind, the eye if the heart, where our only desire is the well-being of all creatures. We tend to listen more than define our boundary lines; Seeing in the eyes of the enemy as we are, a child of God and blessed enough to have a friend like Frank to help us along the way.

“Where There is No Love, Put Love and You Will Find Love”

Easter 6, John 15:

“Where There is No Love, Put Love and You Will Find Love”

Herbert O’Driscoll described John’s Gospel as a “remembering” of what the life of the Christ was to John and his community. His attempt to describe the meaning of The Christ as self-emptying love is, I think hugely successful. This spiritual master was on the downward path, mixing with the forgotten and the lost. Christ descends before he ascends.  St Francis de Sales poignantly wrote about this spiritual path of descent in the title of this reflection, ”Where there is no love, put love and you will find love”. There is no place that the Christ and by extension the Mercy and love of God will not reach, where God’s yearning for union with us is absent.

Perhaps one of the most telling parts of the creed that some of us say each Sunday is: “He descended into hell.” Even in hell, one finds the presence and mercy of God. And as one survivor of one of Hitler’s Death camps reported, “I’ve already been to hell.” It is the Hebrew God of Moses who sees the affliction of the people Israel. Israel means “to wrestle with God”, and God seeing these wrestlers in the hell of slavery, calls Moses to lead them to their liberation. For Christians, the Christ is a personification of that loving descent of God into the hell of our lives, those moments when there is only the sense of extreme separation. Even there God comes.

Evelyn Underhill transcribes the story of a holy man who when asked if he could be present to Christ in hell, remarked, “I’d rather be with Christ in hell than in heaven without Him.”

The point that John makes is that there is a constant outpouring of love: from the Divine, love overflows into the Christ and through the Christ into the Spirit and from the Spirit into us. And as the divine love and mercy flows back to the divine the endless exchange of love continues to overflow into the creation.

John faces the breakdown of the overflow of the divine love sixty or seventy years after the death of Jesus. His community is broken, the people have returned to the easier gods of the empire, there is already persecution of the new Christians as well as the Jews. It was not only the Temple that was destroyed within the memory of John, but the systematic extermination of the Jews in Jerusalem and parts of North Africa. By extension the new Christian communities still identified with the Jews also fell victim to the Roman extermination campaign.

If John chose to distance himself from the Jews it was perhaps his fear in the face of this systematic persecution. Ever since it seems only the greatest saints have stood with the Jews when they faced subsequent persecutions. History testifies that many Christians ended up as their executioners or remained silent at their oppression.

If we are to love one another, how are we to do it in a way that keeps us open to the flow of God’s love as it moves and flows through people and time and nature? It is through descent, modeled in the self-emptying love of the Christ for the poor, the forgotten and for the suffering. It is there, in the hells of Auschwitz, in the hell of being targeted in a racist society, in the suffering from earthquake, famine, oppression, that love, when it is put, love can be found.

In spite of his fear, John described the process as a continual motion of flow and exchange where love’s power and energy is sustained and grows. It is that energy that Albert Einstein’s daughter recently shared in a letter from her father. In it he said that the real spiritual energy of the universe is not E= MC 2. Her father’s final letter to humanity is E=LOVE. And so it flows, spilling over into the universe, a force that builds, that renews, and re-envisions what it means to be human. John recognized the power of the energy of love a while ago now, I only wish we hadn’t used it as an instrument of oppression.